Conservatives battered in native elections as losses mount

Unlock the Editor’s Digest without cost

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.

Rishi Sunak’s Conservatives have been hammered in native elections throughout England and Wales and misplaced the Blackpool South parliamentary by-election to Labour, however threats of a mutiny in opposition to the prime minister have receded.

Sunak’s get together comfortably held on to the totemic Conservative mayoralty of Tees Valley, easing fears in Downing Avenue {that a} catastrophic set of outcomes would set off an rebellion in opposition to his management by Tory MPs.

Early returns within the final huge check earlier than a common election anticipated this 12 months instructed that the UK’s governing get together might lose half the council seats it was defending.

The outcomes have been on the higher finish of Tory MPs’ worst fears and Sunak described the lack of Conservative councillors as “disappointing”.

Against this, Labour chief Sir Keir Starmer mentioned on Friday that the 26 per cent swing to his get together in Blackpool was “seismic”.

Sunak is struggling to keep up a grip on a Conservative get together that usually seems exhausted after being in workplace since 2010, and continues to be struggling the after-effects of Liz Truss’s disastrous and shortlived management.

However in a victory on Friday that calmed nerves, the Tories held on to the Tees Valley mayoralty with a lowered however snug majority of 18,789. Lord Ben Houchen, the incumbent, stays a well-liked native determine and tried to distance himself from the get together’s woes at Westminster.

Conservatives are hopeful that Andy Avenue, Tory mayor of West Midlands, may even maintain on, with Labour insiders saying that Starmer’s place on the Gaza conflict might have price the get together Muslim votes.

Early indicators have been that rightwing Conservative critics of Sunak would pull again from making an attempt to topple him. “A powerful ‘keep calm’ message goes across the WhatsApp teams,” mentioned one former cupboard minister.

Dame Andrea Jenkyns, a Boris Johnson supporter who submitted a no-confidence letter in Sunak final November, instructed the BBC: “It’s wanting unlikely that the MPs are going to place the letters in. So we’ve bought to tug collectively.”

One Tory insurgent insider mentioned a few of Sunak’s critics within the parliamentary get together have been now reluctantly rallying behind him, including: “Tees Valley has given folks an off-ramp.”

Projections that the Conservatives might lose half the council seats they held have been based mostly on leads to 53 of the 107 councils being contested; some voters in England and Wales have been additionally electing mayors in addition to police and crime commissioners.

Sir John Curtice, the veteran elections skilled, mentioned the outcomes have been “not far brief” of catastrophic for the Conservatives and “one of many worst, if not the worst” end result for the get together in native elections for 40 years.

Starmer’s in a single day focus was on Labour’s parliamentary by-election victory, the place the brand new MP, Chris Webb, beat the Conservatives’ David Jones with a 26 per cent swing. Reform UK got here a slender third, simply 117 votes behind the Conservatives.

“This seismic win in Blackpool South is crucial end result right this moment,” Starmer mentioned. “That is the one contest the place voters had the prospect to ship a message to Rishi Sunak’s Conservatives immediately, and that message is an awesome vote for change.”

Labour’s victory in Blackpool South was its third-biggest swing in opposition to the Conservatives in a postwar by-election and is ominous for Tory MPs defending comparable working-class seats within the “crimson wall” of northern England.

Labour overturned a Tory majority of three,690 votes to take the parliamentary seat with a 7,607 majority. The seat was previously held by Scott Benton, who was pressured to give up in a lobbying scandal.

Reform UK, previously the Brexit get together, secured 17 per cent of the vote in Blackpool South, one of many races it targeted on, after standing candidates for less than 12 per cent of contested council seats.

The truth that Reform UK, based by Nigel Farage, didn’t come second shall be one crumb of consolation for Tory strategists, though its efficiency was one other reminder of how it’s splitting the vote on the suitable.

A Conservative spokesperson mentioned: “What has been clear is {that a} vote for Reform is a vote for Sir Keir Starmer.”

It was not all excellent news for Labour. The get together misplaced management of Oldham council in Better Manchester, after ceding a number of seats to independents who stood on a pro-Palestine platform. It additionally misplaced seats in Newcastle.

Pat McFadden, Labour’s elections co-ordinator, admitted that the Gaza conflict was costing the get together votes. “There’s no denying this can be a think about some elements of the nation,” he mentioned.

The Conservatives additionally narrowly held on to energy in Harlow in Essex, a Conservative-Labour battleground seat wherein Starmer had campaigned this week. Sunak seized on the end result as proof that the Tories might halt Labour’s advance.

As counting continued on Friday afternoon, Labour had made web features of 86 council seats in opposition to 148 Tory losses.

Labour additionally received the newly enlarged North East mayoralty. Its candidate Kim McGuinness overcame former Labour mayor Jamie Driscoll, who was standing as an impartial. 

Put your inquiries to George Parker and colleagues at a webinar for FT subscribers on Wednesday 8 Might 1300-1400 UK (GMT+1). Register at ft.com/ukwebinar